Featuring Thomas Duvernay, PhD | Sinmiyangyo: The 1871 Conflict Between the United States and Korea
When American warships steamed into Korean waters in 1871, they ignited more than just cannon fire—they opened a chapter of resistance, cultural clash, and a legacy that still echoes today. This week, historian Dr. Thomas Duvernay guides us through the Shinmiyangyo (신미양요), the United States’ ill-fated “punitive expedition” against Joseon Korea. From the diplomatic missteps that provoked conflict to the dramatic siege of Ganghwa Island’s forts, we unpack why this little-known clash matters—and how it shaped Korea’s cautious stance toward the West.
Join our Patreon to get more stuff
https://patreon.com/darksideofseoul
Book a tour of The Dark Side of Seoul Ghost Walk at https://darksideofseoul.com
Credits
Produced by Joe McPherson and Shawn Morrissey
Music by Soraksan
Top Tier Patrons
Angel Earl
Joel Bonomini
Devon Hiphner
Gabi Palomino
Steve Marsh
Eva Sikora
Hunter Winter
Cecilia Löfgren Dumas
Ashley Wright
Edward Bradford
Boram Yoon
Chad Struhs
Stewart MacMillan
Louise Dreisig
Clash of Gunboats and Tradition:
Unpacking the 1871 Shinmiyangyo with Dr. Thomas Duvernay
In the spring of 1871, a fleet of five U.S. naval vessels anchored off Ganghwa Island, Korea. They also aimed to press for diplomatic engagement with Korea, which remained firmly closed to foreign contact. The next event was the Shinmiyangyo (신미양요). This was the “Western Disturbance of the Sinmi Year.” It marked a brief but bloody clash between the United States and Joseon Korea. The battle left Korean fortresses in ruins and American forces claiming a costly “victory.”
Why Shinmiyangyo Matters
A Turning Point
This was Korea’s first direct military confrontation with a Western power. The encounter foreshadowed the series of unequal treaties and foreign interventions that would follow in the late 19th century.
Diplomatic Disaster
What began as an effort at negotiation quickly escalated. This was due to mutual suspicion, miscommunication, and cultural misunderstandings. These issues transformed a diplomatic mission into an armed conflict.
Legacy of Resistance
The Korean defenders of Ganghwa Island’s forts became enduring symbols of national pride. They embodied resistance to foreign intrusion. These events shaped Korean attitudes toward outsiders for decades.
Key Moments Explored
The Incident That Sparked It
The General Sherman incident in 1866 was significant. The American ship was destroyed, and its crew was killed after a failed attempt to open trade. This incident remained unresolved. In 1871, U.S. officials demanded answers, but Joseon authorities refused to engage, wary of foreign intentions.
The Naval Show of Force
Rear Admiral John Rodgers commanded five warships and over 1,200 men. About 650 sailors and Marines landed on Ganghwa Island. They wielded modern rifles and artillery. These weapons far outmatched the Korean defenders’ matchlocks and antiquated cannons.
Siege of Ganghwa Forts
On June 10–11, 1871, U.S. forces assaulted several Korean forts. Despite fierce resistance, the Americans captured and dismantled the fortifications. Korean casualties were heavy—over 240 killed—while the Americans suffered three dead and ten wounded.
Aftermath and Treaties
Despite their battlefield success, the Americans failed to secure a treaty or open Korean ports. The U.S. withdrew. Korea’s isolationist policies held firm until the 1882 Shufeldt Treaty with the United States. This occurred several years after Japan’s own opening of Korea in 1876.
Insights from Dr. Thomas Duvernay
Cultural Blind Spots
Dr. Duvernay highlights how American officers did not understand or respect Korean diplomatic protocol. This lack of understanding turned a tense standoff into a punitive military raid.
Local Perspectives
Korean commanders chose to fight against overwhelming odds, guided by a sense of duty and honor. Their strategies and sacrifices are still studied as examples of resilience.
Long-Term Impact
The Shinmiyangyo deepened Korean suspicion of foreign powers. It reinforced the country’s isolationist stance. These factors shaped Korea’s responses to later diplomatic and military pressures.
Why You Should Care
The Shinmiyangyo is a vivid case study of 19th-century imperialism—where technology, cultural differences, and miscommunication collided with tragic results. In an era of renewed global tensions, its lessons about diplomacy, respect, and unintended consequences remain as relevant as ever.
Listen to the Full Interview
Tune in to hear Dr. Duvernay’s vivid reconstructions. Discover the untold stories behind this pivotal moment in Korean and American history.
Leave a Reply