Rise of the Scholar Elite (1560s-1580s) | Fall of Joseon, part 6

Korea’s 300-year of rule by, of, and for the scholarly elite begins. But of course there must be intrigue, torture, and death. It’s the Joseon Dynasty.

Join our Patreon to get more stuff

https://patreon.com/darksideofseoul

Book a tour of The Dark Side of Seoul Ghost Walk at https://darksideofseoul.com

Credits

Produced by Joe McPherson and Shawn Morrissey

Music by Soraksan

Top Tier Patrons

Angel Earl
Joel Bonomini
Shaaron Cullen
Devon Hiphner
Gabi Palomino
Steve Marsh
Mitchy Brewer
Ron Chang
Mackenzie Moore
Hunter Winter
Cecilia Löfgren Dumas
Emily Umbaugh
Josephine Rydberg
David Weatherly
Janice Song
Devin Buchanan
Edward Bradford

Rise of the Scholar Elite (1560s-1580s) | Fall of Joseon, Part 6: Factional Strife and the Birth of Joseon’s Scholar-Rule Dynasty

In this episode of The Fall of Joseon, we explore the rise of the scholar elite during the 1560s-1580s, a period that marked the beginning of Joseon’s rule “by, of, and for the scholarly elite.” However, this era, as with all periods in Joseon history, was steeped in intrigue, political infighting, and bloody purges. The scholar elite became the most powerful faction in Joseon politics, consolidating their influence while deeply entangled in factional strife that would shape the kingdom for centuries.

Previously on The Fall of Joseon…

After King Injong’s death, his young successor, King Myeongjong, was thrust into a turbulent political landscape where factionalism and infighting dominated the court. Queen Mother Munjeong’s regency was supported by her powerful brothers, the Yun family. This eventually led to the Literati Purge of 1545, as rival factions clashed and eliminated their opposition. Despite these purges, the Junior-Yun Faction gained power, though their reign was short-lived, and by the time Myeongjong’s reign concluded, new political dynamics began to emerge, paving the way for the rise of the scholar elite.

The Emergence of the Scholar Elite

The 1560s-1580s witnessed the consolidation of the Confucian scholar elite’s power, as the government shifted toward a system based on merit rather than royal bloodlines. King Myeongjong, with the help of influential scholar officials like Sim Uigyeom, began appointing Confucian scholars to key positions. This era marked the birth of a government “by, of, and for the scholarly elite.” The scholar officials were rewarded with land, tax exemptions, and influential positions, while wielding significant power over Joseon politics.

By this time, Joseon had a growing class of merit-subjects (Gongsin), who could inherit land and titles and gain wealth and power through government service. These officials, numbering 526 by King Myeongjong’s reign, dominated the government bureaucracy and military leadership. Their power continued to grow, with major political factions emerging in response to the increased influence of scholars in governance.

Factional Strife and Political Struggles

Despite their growing influence, the scholar elite were far from unified. Factionalism (Dangjaeng) became a defining feature of Joseon politics, as officials battled for power within the rigid Confucian system. The emergence of the East and West Factions was a direct result of personal ambitions and political maneuvering among these scholar-officials.

King Seonjo, who ascended the throne in 1567, presided over a turbulent period of factional conflict. The East and West factions engaged in bitter struggles over government appointments, particularly within the ranks of middle-ranking personnel officials, a key source of political influence. In 1567, Gi Daeseung, a young official, launched an attack to restore the honor of purged officials from the 1545 purge. This caused a two-year-long battle between the younger and older factions, with officials like Yi I and Yi Jungyeong vying for dominance.

Simultaneously, factionalism intensified as the Dongin (East Faction) and Seoin (West Faction) split over key issues, including the handling of purged officials. These early conflicts marked the beginning of the bitter “Factional Politics” that would persist throughout the Joseon Dynasty. By 1575, factional politics had become entrenched, with the East Faction gaining the upper hand under King Seonjo’s reign.

Scholar Elite’s Growing Influence

As the scholar elite grew in influence, they wielded power over the government’s political and military systems. Confucian academies became recruiting grounds for future scholar-officials, and these factions began to dominate the political landscape. However, the competition for office and position led to widespread corruption, as officials sought to stack the government with their own supporters.

Joseon’s scholar elites were highly educated and believed their success in government service was a result of their Confucian virtues. However, their refusal to engage in productive economic activities left many scholars impoverished, with most relying on government positions for their livelihood. This intense competition for government service led to a fierce struggle for key positions, further intensifying the factionalism that plagued the government.

The Struggle for Political Power

One of the major causes of factionalism in Joseon was the fierce competition for key government positions. The Dongin and Seoin factions, divided between moderates and hardliners, battled for control of military and political posts. Yi I, a prominent scholar of the West Faction, attempted to mediate between the two factions but ultimately failed. His neutral stance, arguing that both sides were correct and wrong, led to his downfall, and the East Faction gained further power.

Simultaneously, the growing influence of Confucian academies played a significant role in shaping Joseon politics. These academies, often divided by geographic region, were hotbeds of political activity. As the East and West Factions fought for dominance, they used the academies as tools to train loyalists and gather support.

Political Repercussions and Bloody Purges

As factionalism deepened, the Gichuk-oksa Purge of 1589 became a turning point in the conflict. The Daedonggye Conspiracy, led by Jeong Yeorip, led to a bloody purge, with over 1,000 scholars and officials executed or exiled. This purge was a direct result of political competition and the desire to eliminate rivals. Jeong Cheol, a leader of the East Faction, took charge of the purge, and in his zeal, he even went as far as to torture and kill members of the East Faction who were seen as traitors.

As Joseon society fractured under the weight of these internal struggles, the scholar elite’s role in the government became more pronounced. However, their dominance would soon face external challenges, as Japan’s invasion plans began to unfold.

Conclusion: A Kingdom Divided

The rise of the scholar elite in the 1560s-1580s laid the foundation for the power dynamics of Joseon for centuries. The political and military struggles, fueled by factionalism, tore at the fabric of the kingdom. Despite their growing influence, the scholar elite’s focus on internal competition and their refusal to address external threats left Joseon vulnerable to invasion. As we look ahead in the Fall of Joseon series, we will explore how these internal divisions played a role in the kingdom’s response to the Japanese invasion and its eventual downfall.

---

Key Takeaways:

• Factionalism in Joseon: The rise of the scholar elite led to a bitter rivalry between the East and West Factions, marking the beginning of a long history of political infighting.
• Confucian Influence: Confucian values played a central role in shaping Joseon politics, but they also fostered a rigid and hierarchical system that encouraged competition and power struggles.
• The Scholar Elite’s Power: The scholar elite solidified their control over Joseon’s government and military, but their factionalism and refusal to address external threats ultimately weakened the kingdom.
• Purges and Repression: The internal power struggles led to bloody purges and political repression, resulting in widespread violence and the stifling of dissent.

---

Stay tuned for more episodes of The Fall of Joseon, where we continue to explore the complex history, intrigue, and power struggles that shaped one of the longest-lasting dynasties in East Asian history.